Health Telematics (AIM) Final Report
 
|
|
Updated: Feb 1, 97
|
ESTEEM |
European Standardised Telematic Tool to Evaluate Electromyographic Knowledge-Based Systems and Methods
| Project Code: | | A2010 |
| Project value: | | 2527 KECU |
| EC contribution: | | 1318 KECU |
| No of partners: | | 4 |
| No of countries: | | 4 |
| Duration: | | 36 months |
| Contact:
Dr. Mario Veloso
Hospital Egas Moniz
Dept. Neurology
Rua da Jungueira 126
P-1300 Lisboa, Portugal
Tel.: +351-1-362.00.50 / 362.23.10
Fax: +351-1-363.34.09
|
Overview
All industrialised countries have expressed great hopes that expert systems will contribute to a more efficient medicine. Pooling specialised expertise in a widely distributed information system over Europe could be a way to overcome the increasing complexity of the medical domain and insure that the most appropriate cure is offered to each patient. Prototype research is already done in the USA and in Japan, but Europe, with the diversity of its cultures and its high education level, could become a leader in the domain.
ESTEEM has approached the problem from a very pragmatic angle. In order to ensure success within a reasonable time, it concentrated on a well circumscribed domain of medicine: electromyography. Still, it built a general tool for developing and testing knowledge based systems but applied it, as a pilot, only to electromyography. Such a restriction is essential for a critical assessment of the expert systems technique and it is the first step to a generalisation in other medical domains.
Purpose and objectives
The overall goal of the ESTEEM project is to develop a prototype telematics system in Clinical Neurophysiology - Electromyography (EMG) - assisting the neurophysiologist in his/her clinical daily routine from data management to decision-making and quality assurance. More specifically, ESTEEM aims at integrating EMG decision support systems (i.e. EMG knowledge-based systems) into a coherent EMG information processing environment to be used in the daily practice together with a set of quality assurance methods and tools for the assessment of those systems and of the individual clinical EMG practice, in the context of a European EMG information network. A deep collaboration between the clinical experts representing eight leading European EMG centres and the technical specialist group from the industry and the university provided important achievements briefly described as follows.
Results
- Successful development of an integration environment (version 3 prototype), entitled the EMG-Platform, on which several different kinds of application modules can be plugged into. Major components of this EMG-Platform are:
- the EASE kernel providing a general solution for how to integrate other systems into the platform;
- the ECP (ESTEEM Communication Protocol) providing the means for exchange of EMG data;
- the EMG data entry tool, now entitled the Electronic EMG Patient Record (EEPR),
for the acquisition and analysis of the EMG data sets from the different EMG centres in the work of building up the ESTEEM multicentre consensus database;
- the ESTEEM database containing consensus cases;
- Illustrating its open architecture several distinct application prototypes have been already interfaced into the EMG-Platform:
- the KANDID KBS module for the planning and diagnosis support of EMG studies;
- the HINT system (High-level Inferencing Tool), an expert system for the interpretation of neurophysiological studies;
- the DEMONSTRATOR prototype, a second generation of a EMG knowledge-based system based on a causal functional approach;
- the NeuroMyosis system; and
- the ET (Evaluation Tool) prototype including an automatic EMG case generation from the ESTEEM database for testing knowledge-based systems credibility.
- Established a growing, committed, European network of clinical users promoting the incorporation and utilisation of these new technologies into disseminated clinical utilisation and which delivered important clinical achievements:
- A complete and update specification of the structure of a common general usable EMG data set covering all used EMG examination techniques and including higher level interpretations.
- Developed terminology for the representation of EMG data in a coherent and consistent way.
- Collected and analysed 700 EMG cases retrospectively for documenting the factual differences among the involved EMG laboratories.
- Performed an extensive collection of EMG data cases providing information about the use of examination techniques, diagnostic criteria, planning strategies, etc.
- Developed a procedure for seeking consensus on diagnoses and pathophysiologic states of anatomical structures, representing a truly medical audit of EMG cases, on a European basis.
- Implemented a multicentre EMG database containing EMG patient cases with attached consensus diagnoses.
Benefits for users:
The ESTEEM database already constitutes a valuable reference material for good medical practice in EMG which in combination with the evaluation tools incorporated in the EMG-Platform offer new possibilities for systematic in depth assessment of EMG knowledge-based systems as well as of individual EMG practice. This together with the established international audit procedure to seek consensus already offers unique potentialities for a better practice in the field of clinical neurophysiology.
In addition, in the near future, with the EMG-Platform applied and used in the daily routine in the eight different ESTEEM EMG centres, a truly telematic environment for clinical EMG in
Europe will be then established where:
- data acquisition from local EMG machines to the EMG-Platform will become automated
- EMG cases can easily be circulated and discussed between experts from different sites
- applications of different kinds (e.g. Electronic EMG patient record systems, databases and
EMG KBSs) can communicate and collaborate.
Plans for exploitation:
The EMG-Platform is actually a pre-industrial product. However, it is planned to mature this system into an operational product. Dantec Medical - Danish medium sized company has decided to incorporate the EMG-Platform vs 3 into their new product development strategy and activities. In addition, it has been decided to install and finalise the EMG- Platform technology to an operational routine system at the department of clinical neurophysiology at the Gentofte Hospital in Copenhagen.
The planned incorporation of ESTEEM prototypes onto the integrating Hospital Information System environment being implemented in ISAR project enables on site external clinical user validation of ESTEEM achievements. This together with the several presentations in scientific meetings of ESTEEM contribute both to the dissemination of ESTEEM results and to the impact at the neurophysiology medical community and standardisation bodies (i.e. CEN 25 l ) as to the emergent standards in the field.
Many requests from other EMG centres to join the international audit and consensus process of ESTEEM have been received. The Clinical user group of ESTEEM is currently considering to establish an organisation which can handle a world-wide network for this activity incorporating several national sub-nets which can continue and extend this important process leading to new effective methods and guidelines for quality assurance.
List of Deliverables
- Specification of the kernel of the EMG-Platform
- Specification of a common EMG dataset
- Specification and design of the EMG -Platform
- Clinical considerations for the standardisation and evaluation in the context of EMG
- EMG-Platform
- EMG Multi-centre database
- Evaluation methods for knowledge-based EMG systems
List of Participants
Pr. Anders Fuglsang-Frederiksen
Gentofte Hospital
Niels Andersens Vej 65
DK-2900 Hellerup, Denmark
Tel.: +45-31-65.12.00
Fax: +45-31-68.16.98
| Dr. Annick Vila
Univ. Joseph Fourier
Faculte de Medicine
Mathematique & Informat.Medicale
F-38706 Grenoble, France
Tel.: +33-76-63.71.47
Fax: +33-76-51.86.67
|
Prof. Pedro Barahona
UNINOVA
Campus da FCT/UNL
P-2825 Monte da Caparica, Portugal
Tel.: +351-1-295.32.20
Fax: +351-1-295.56.41
E-mail: pb@fct.unl.pt
| |
 |
 |
 |
|
Copyright 1997 © EHTO All rights reserved
This server is the only official EHTO WWW knowledge repository.
Mail suggestions to: webmaster@ehto.org
|